Cerave eye cream vs. Kiehl’s vs. RoC: Which is best?

From bestreviews.com
Lizzy Briskin

Dermatologists recommend using a cream once or twice a day to smooth skin and stop skin damage before it starts.

Comparing Cerave, Kiehl’s and RoC eye creams 

Taking care of the sensitive and delicate skin around your eyes is essential, no matter your age. One of the best ways to keep your skin supple, smooth and hydrated is to apply high-quality eye cream regularly. 

A good eye cream can also help reduce inflammation and keep your skin moisturized. The best eye creams are gentle on your skin and contain clean ingredients. And depending on your needs, the right eye cream will address dark spots, wrinkles, dry skin or oily skin. 

Cerave, Kiehl’s and RoC are the three leading cosmetic brands and have an avid fan base. To help cut through the marketing lingo, here’s a list of what you need to know about their eye creams and how to find the right product for you. 

Cerave eye cream

Cerave makes skincare products that treat specific skin concerns, and dermatologists recommend them for various issues, including acne, dry skin and more. Their company relies on clinical ingredients like benzoyl peroxide and hyaluronic acid to keep skin clear and smooth.  

The Cerave Eye Repair Cream has hyaluronic acid, extra hydration and ceramides to restore the skin’s natural barrier and keep the skin hydrated. This eye cream comes in a 0.5-ounce tube for $10-$15 each. You can find it at Ulta Beauty

The Eye Repair Cream is a great option for a soothing and moisturizing eye cream without breaking the bank. It’s great for people who want to keep their skin hydrated and prevent damage. 

Cerave eye cream pros

  • The cream is ophthalmologist-tested for eye safety, so you can use it twice a day.
  • It includes marine-derived ingredients that brighten the skin around the eyes to minimize dark circles and reduce puffiness.
  • Many users notice tighter, brighter skin in less than two months with regular use.

Cerave eye cream cons

  • Some users with naturally oily skin felt that the eye cream did not absorb easily and has an oily feel.

Best Cerave eye creams

The Eye Repair Cream from Cerave is the best product in their eye cream collection. The soft, light cream can brighten and hydrate skin with dermatologist-approved ingredients.

Kiehl’s eye cream

Kiehl’s was one of the first American companies to list their ingredients on the label. Today, the brand upholds its commitment to transparency and uses quality, functional ingredients. 

Like all of Kiehl’s products, their line of eye creams is formulated to address specific concerns. Whether want to reduce dark circles with the Vitamin C Eye Serum available at Sephora, or smooth out your skin with the Powerful Wrinkle Reducing Eye Cream, also available at Sephora, there is a Kiehl’s product for everyone. 

Kiehl’s eye creams cost between $25-$50, depending on the size of the container and the strength of the ingredients. 

Kiehl’s eye cream pros

  • Kiehl’s eye creams have effective ingredients that are great for your skin, like retinol and grape seed oil. 
  • Each product addresses specific skin conditions, so you can narrow down your search based on your needs.

Kiehl’s eye cream cons

  • Because Kiehl’s eye cream offers so many options, it can be difficult to find the right product for your skin.
  • Kiehl’s products tend to be more expensive than drug-store brands.

Best Kiehl's eye creams

The best all-around eye cream from Kiehl’s is the Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado, which is available at Sephora, Macy’s and Ulta Beauty. It comes in a half-ounce container for around $30. 

This light, cooling eye cream soothes skin and provides deep moisture overnight or during the day. It’s gentle enough to use twice a day and works under makeup, so you don’t have to worry about your makeup running. 

This product is also fragrance-free and contains no parabens, making it a good choice for sensitive skin. It keeps the entire eye area bright, refreshed and de-puffed. 

RoC eye cream

The RoC beauty brand is known for putting potent ingredients like retinol and vitamin C in their products to help smooth and brighten the skin. They make everything from serums to creams to address uneven, dull skin. Their eye creams are no different and come in an over-the-counter retinol treatment to reduce puffiness. And at around $15 per half-ounce tube, their products are both affordable and effective. 

RoC eye cream pros

  • RoC offers an inexpensive eye cream option with powerful ingredients to smooth the skin and fight skin damage.  
  • Users had success reducing puffiness and circles under their eyes after regular use for two months.

RoC eye cream cons

  • Some users with sensitive skin had adverse reactions to the eye cream, including rashes. 

Best RoC eye creams

If you want a strong, daily eye cream that keeps skin looking fresh, the RoC Retinol Correxion Line Smoothing AntiAging Eye Cream is a great option. It’s available at Amazon and Ulta Beauty

This is a great product that goes on smooth without a sheen and works for all skin types, including dry, oily and combination. 

Should you get Cerave, Kiehl’s or Roc?

At the end of the day, the correct eye cream comes down to your skin type. If you need a first-time eye cream to minimize puffiness and uneven skin tone, Cerave products are an excellent and affordable option. 

For something a little more expensive product with more natural ingredients, Kiehl’s eye cream is gentle and all-purpose. Or, if you have a specific concern you’d like to address, there is likely a Kiehl’s product with your name on it. 

On the other hand, RoC offers a hard-fighting eye cream that specifically addresses skin damage. It’s also an inexpensive but high-quality choice.

Before shelling out any money for these eye creams, consider what you’d like the product to do. Take a look at the ingredients to ensure there’s nothing that will inflame the delicate area around your eyes. Once you’ve found the right eye cream for your beauty routine, use it regularly to see the best results.  

Lizzy Briskin is a writer for BestReviews. BestReviews is a product review company with a singular mission: to help simplify your purchasing decisions and save you time and money.

BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. BestReviews and its newspaper partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.