Best and Worst Sports Drinks

Best and Worst Sports Drinks

Endurox Accelerade: Fruit Punch, $35

Drink It Or Toss It: Toss It

Coming in dead last, Endurox Accelerade received brutal reviews. It was described as "pink bile" and "vomit after a rough night of sugary cocktails and tacos." Each scoop of the drink contains 20g of sugar, five grams of protein, 120 calories, vitamins C and E, and other nutrients. 

PowerBar Recovery: Orange, $28

Drink It Or Toss It:  Toss It

This beverage, described as watered-down tang, left a lot to be desired.

"I gagged and had to force myself to swallow," wrote one reviewer. 

One scoop of PowerBar Recovery contains 90 calories, three grams of protein and 10g of sugar.

Spartos Protein Water: Strawberry + Coconut, $30 (Pack of 12)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Toss It

The flavor of this drink was described as "very odd." The protein comes from whey, leaving the beverage with a milky taste that does not meld well with the coconut and strawberry flavors. 

Greater Than Berry Blue Coconut Water, $26.77 (Pack of 12)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Toss It

Our judges could not identify the taste of this drink (guesses ranged from "berry candy" to "cardboard"),  but each gave Berry Blue a thumbs down. 

Still, the beverage boasts half the sugar and two times the electrolytes of leading sports drinks. Each serving has 30 calories, 135mg of potassium, seven grams of sugar and eight grams of carbohydrates.

Muscle Milk Banana Crème, $51.93 (Pack of 12)

Drink It Or Toss It: Toss It

While the smell was reminiscent of graham crackers, the taste was alternately described as vanilla, flavored soy milk and "an aspartame-covered banana split." Still, this drink packs 25g of protein and manages a creamy texture while being lactose free.

Greater Than Tropical Coconut Water, $30 (Pack of 12)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Toss It

A step up from the Berry Blue, this Greater Than product still left something to be desired. The taste begins "light and fruity, but a little bland" and ends with the same cardboard taste of the previous sample.

Pur Pak: Citrus, $18 (10 day Sample Box)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Drink It

Reminiscent of Emergen-C, Pur Pak Citrus has a sour taste and the smell of a creamsicle. The product is full of antioxidants, vitamins and minerals, including coenzyme Q10, vitamin C, iron, potassium, glucosamine and chondroiton. Each tablet has only 15 calories and two grams of sugar and is made without artificial colors, dyes or sweeteners.

PowerBar Perform, $24

Drink It Or Toss It:  Drink It

Powerbar Perform has a slightly watery, lemon-lime flavor, however consumers can add more powder to suit their tastes. Each scoop has 70 calories, 10 grams of sugar, 17g of carbohydrate and 190mg of sodium.

ZYM Endurance Lemon Lime, $23.97 (3 tubes - 30 tabs)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Drink It

With a light lemon flavor reminiscent of JELL-O, Zym was described as "the least sugary of the bunch." In a single tablet, there are just seven calories, a single gram of sugar and nutrients including vitamins C and B6.

Vitamin Water Zero Power-C Dragonfruit $46.50 (Pack of 24)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Drink It

Reviewers were divided on this product. While some described it as too sweet, another was "pleasantly surprised by the lack of sweetness." While there are no calories in Vitamin Water Zero, you'll still get a heavy dose of vitamins B6, B12 and C, as well as zinc. The concoction is made up of mostly recognizeable ingredients, including reverse osmosis water and color from vegetable juice.

Cytomax Sports Performance Drink: Grape, $20.95 (24-count)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Drink It

With a tart, grape taste, this product serves up 90 calories, 12g of sugar and nutrients including vitamins A and C.

Vitalyte Tri-Phase Endurance: Watermelon, $1.75

Drink It Or Toss It:  Drink It

The Sweet Tarts taste of of Vitalyte can also be made weaker or stronger, depending on your preference. The drink has 100 calories per serving and a potent dose of B vitamins to help you stay focused and mentally tough.

Nuun Active Hydration Cherry Limeade, $24.00 (Pack of 4)

Drink It Or Toss It: Drink It

This slightly carbonated drink was described as having a cola or bubble gum taste. The electrolyte blend has no sugar, but a solid serving of potassium, sodium and magnesium, as well as 20mg of caffeine. No artificial flavors or colors are used in Nuun products.

Gatorade Frost Glacier Cherry Thirst Quencher, $51.52 (Pack of 12)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Drink It

In 2013, Gatorade re-launched Frost, a drink that serves up 80 calories, 21g of sugar and 45mg of potassium. Reviewers gave the light, sweet flavor solid scores.

Muscle Milk Cookies 'N Crème $47.88 (Pack of 12)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Drink It

Tasters described Muscle Milk Cookies N' Creme as a "protein-packed pinch in the mouth" with mocha and vanilla flavors. They also commented on its exceptionally sweet taste:

"I have a hard time believing this is any better than drinking a milkshake," one wrote. But can a milkshake boast 25g of protein and just three grams of sugar? (Note: we're still not sure how Muscle Milk gets its sweet taste, given that no artificial sweeteners were listed.)

G Recover Protein Shake: Chocolate, $51.99 (Pack of 12)

Drink It Or Toss It:  Drink It

Far and away, the winner of this competition was the chocolate protein shake from Gatorade. One judge enthusiastically referred to the flavor as the "rich chocolate-milk taste you fondly remember being served at the school cafeteria." At 270 calories, this drink packs 20g of protein, 20g of sugar and 35 percent of your daily calcium.